Is CrossFit Really to Blame? A Look at Elite Burnout vs. Everyday Training
This may not be on your radar depending on whether you follow the sport of CrossFit, but in recent years, a handful of former high-level CrossFit athletes have shared that their years of training “beat them up” and that they’ve since transitioned to lower-intensity training programs—often their own—that they now sell to the general public (and it still has a CrossFit . It’s a compelling story: high-intensity left them broken, and now they’ve found the real path to health.
But here’s the thing—it’s not the CrossFit methodology that left them beat up. It was how they trained within it. And for everyday people seeking lifelong fitness, CrossFit done right is still one of the most effective and scalable paths to health, longevity, and performance.
Let’s break it down.
Elite Training ≠ Everyday Training
When these former athletes say CrossFit left them “wrecked,” it’s important to understand they weren’t doing what the average CrossFitter does.
They were training like full-time professionals—two, sometimes three sessions per day. Heavy lifts, skill sessions, conditioning pieces, gymnastics, aerobic work, mobility, recovery work, sponsorship demands, competitions… rinse and repeat, often for years.
That level of training isn’t healthy—it’s not meant to be. It’s optimized for short-term performance at the expense of long-term balance. They also tended to workout alone and lost connection to the close-knit community that makes CrossFit so special.
They weren’t following CrossFit for health. They were pushing the limits of human performance. That’s a very different goal than what the average CrossFitter pursues. This isn’t limited to the sport of CrossFit but professional and competitive sports in general.
CrossFit, Scaled: The Real Magic for Real People
CrossFit, when practiced with appropriate intensity and smart scaling, isn’t about destruction—it’s about adaptation. It’s functional training designed to help people:
Build lean muscle
Increase bone density
Improve mobility and joint health
Enhance cardiovascular endurance
Boost metabolic health
Reduce the risk of chronic disease
Improve confidence, mental resilience, and community connection
The key phrase here? “With appropriate intensity.”
CrossFit’s greatest strength is that intensity is relative—and it’s scalable.
Do it at a level that is appropriate to your physical, physiological, and psychological tolerances. A 25-year-old firefighter and a 65-year-old retiree can do the same workout—at different loads, ranges of motion, and pacing—and both walk away better for it. In other words, our needs differ by degree, not kind.
Why Intensity Still Matters
There’s a trend in the fitness world pushing low-intensity-only protocols: walking, bodyweight flows, light movement snacks.
And while those things absolutely have a place—they’re not enough by themselves for most people. Here’s why intensity still matters:
Bone density needs loading. As we age, resistance training with enough intensity helps prevent osteoporosis and maintain skeletal strength.
Muscle mass requires challenge. Light movements won’t stimulate muscle growth or maintenance in the same way loaded squats or deadlifts do.
Cardiovascular health thrives on bursts. Interval-style training and high-intensity conditioning improve heart health in ways that casual walking doesn’t match.
Metabolic function improves with stress. Short, intense efforts build insulin sensitivity, mitochondrial health, and fat-burning capacity.
Mental resilience comes from challenge. There’s a unique confidence and clarity that comes from pushing your limits—and learning that you can.
Intensity, done well, is an essential ingredient in healthspan and wellness—not a liability.
Where did it go wrong for the Elites?
It wasn’t CrossFit that failed them. It was:
Volume without balance
Intensity without recovery
Performance prioritized over longevity
They weren’t following a prescription for health—they were chasing peak performance in a sport with extremely high demands. Burnout, injuries, hormonal disruption, and mental fatigue were inevitable at that level of commitment.
That’s not CrossFit’s fault. That’s an occupational hazard of elite competition. Elite marathoners, professional athletes, etc. are not training for long term health. Neither are competitive body builders.
What the General Population Really Needs
For most of us, training isn’t about podiums. It’s about:
Picking up your kids pain-free
Carrying groceries without throwing out your back
Staying mentally sharp and physically capable into your 60s, 70s, and beyond
Feeling confident in your body
Having the energy to enjoy your life outside the gym
CrossFit—done with intention, smart coaching, and individualized scaling—delivers exactly that.
The Bottom Line
Yes, some former athletes that had become household names in the CrossFit space may have stepped away from high-intensity training—but it’s not because the methodology was flawed. It’s because their application of it was extreme, unsustainable, and not designed for long-term wellness.
CrossFit isn’t just for Games athletes. It’s for everyone—when it’s scaled to your needs, your body, and your goals. This methodology and our programming is designed and intended for us to do for decades to come. If done appropriately we can and even should still be doing high-intensity functional training into our 60s, 70s, and longer.
Check out Annie!
You don’t need to train like a pro. You just need to train with purpose. That’s why we provide three variations of the same workout on the board. What are your goals? What season of life are you in? Are you here to just SWEAT and move? Do you want to TRAIN with more of a typical strength and conditioning program? Or would you like to develop the higher skills and strength to COMPETE in competitions?
The leaderboard can be a great tool to help track progress over time but use it as that. Don’t let it consume you or allow your ego to dictate your workout.
“The goal is to get fit, make it the best hour of your day, stay safe, turn up the music, high five some people, and blow off some steam. So, remember that. Relax. Have fun. Workout.” - Pat Sherwood
Need help scaling your workouts to fit your body, life, and goals? That’s what we do best. Our coaches are here to help you through every class. If you’d like to sit down and talk about your goals and come up with a game plan Let’s Chat!
Experience the version of CrossFit that builds you up, not breaks you down.